Tarek Omar Is Calling Out Private Credit’s ‘Garbage Loans’ Problem

The private credit market has become a titan of modern finance, a vital engine providing capital to countless entrepreneurs, startups, and established businesses aiming for growth. This alternative lending world has swelled into a global force of over $3 trillion, stepping in where traditional banks have pulled back. But as the market continues its rapid expansion, a growing chorus of Wall Street experts warns that its foundations are showing signs of stress, raising serious questions for the business leaders who depend on it. These concerns point to a system where escalating complexity and hidden risks could threaten the stability of this crucial funding source.

Wall Street’s $3 Trillion Shadow Bank Is Showing Cracks

For entrepreneurs, access to capital is the lifeblood of innovation, and the private credit sector has largely been a reliable partner. The market is projected to continue its impressive trajectory, with forecasts estimating it will grow from $3.4 trillion in 2025 to nearly $4.9 trillion by 2029. Yet, beneath this success story, prominent financial leaders like Jamie Dimon and Jeffrey Gundlach have begun sounding alarms about the proliferation of what they term “garbage loans.” These are debts issued with weak protections for lenders, often buried within convoluted fund structures that make it difficult for investors to assess the true level of risk. This lack of transparency creates an environment where problems can fester unnoticed until it is too late.

The danger of these opaque debt arrangements is not theoretical; it has already led to significant corporate collapses that rippled through the economy. The failures of companies like First Brands Group and Tricolor Holdings serve as stark cautionary tales, illustrating how intricate debt structures can hide mounting financial distress from investors. When these companies ultimately faltered, the fallout revealed layers of unseen liabilities, leading to a wave of unexpected losses. These events highlight a systemic vulnerability within parts of the private credit market, where the pursuit of higher yields has led some to abandon the foundational principles of prudent underwriting and clear documentation, placing both investor capital and borrower stability in jeopardy.

Tarek Omar, CEO of Royce Stone Capital, warns of growing risks in the private credit market.

A Red Flag Called PIK Interest: The Canary in the Coal Mine

One of the most telling signs of strain within the market is the increasing use of “Payment-in-Kind” (PIK) interest. In simple terms, PIK allows a borrower to pay interest not with cash but by taking on more debt, effectively delaying the actual payment. While this can offer temporary relief to a company facing cash-flow issues, it is often a significant red flag indicating deeper financial struggles. According to market analysis, the rise in PIK structures is a direct response to borrowers’ strained liquidity, a troubling trend suggesting underlying weaknesses are spreading across certain segments of the private credit landscape. This practice can mask the true performance of a loan portfolio, creating a false sense of security for investors.

Watching these developments closely is Tarek Omar, CEO of Royce Stone Capital, an industry insider who is voicing concerns about these specific risks. He points to the data as clear evidence that caution is warranted. “We are observing cracks in the foundations of private credit, especially with the rising use of payment-in-kind interest,” Omar states. He notes that the proportion of transactions featuring PIK components has climbed to 10.6%, a significant jump from 7% in 2021. This statistical shift is not just a footnote; it is a critical distress signal suggesting that a growing number of borrowers cannot generate enough cash to service their debts, a situation that introduces a higher degree of risk for their lenders and investors.

“We are observing cracks in the foundations of private credit, especially with the rising use of payment-in-kind interest,” says Tarek Omar. “It’s a sign that borrowers are strained and that real cash flow may not be supporting the debt.”

The Contrarian View: A Return to Foundational Principles

Tarek Omar is not merely pointing out problems; he is actively advocating for a solution rooted in simplicity, security, and a return to fundamental lending principles. His perspective contrasts with an industry trend of chasing higher returns through increasingly complex financial instruments. Omar’s philosophy prioritizes clear, straightforward underwriting where the value of the underlying security and the borrower’s ability to repay are paramount. This back-to-basics approach dismisses the allure of convoluted structures in favor of a model where every party has a clear understanding of the assets, obligations, and risk involved in every transaction from the outset.

This philosophy is the operational blueprint for his firm, Royce Stone Capital, which champions a direct lending framework that sidesteps many of the risks currently plaguing the broader market. Instead of pooling investor money into an opaque fund, the firm facilitates direct relationships built on tangible security. The model is defined by several key distinctions designed to protect all parties:

Why This Matters for Entrepreneurs and Investors

For entrepreneurs and startup founders, the stability of their capital partner is critical for long-term success. A lender entangled in risky practices and over-leveraged positions may be forced to pull back funding or tighten credit conditions when a growing business needs it most, especially during an economic downturn. Choosing a direct lender who operates with transparency and relies on tangible asset security offers a more stable and predictable partnership. This approach fosters a relationship built on mutual understanding and resilience, rather than one subject to the hidden volatilities of a complex fund structure.

Many successful entrepreneurs are also active investors, and for them, the message is about diligent capital preservation in an uncertain market. In a climate where some funds have been accused of “volatility laundering”—a practice where risk is misrepresented to appear lower than it is—a straightforward, asset-backed model provides a compelling alternative. A structure with direct mortgage security gives an investor a clear, understandable position. This method of generating secured returns stands apart from strategies that rely on financial maneuvering, offering a tangible connection to a real asset rather than a stake in a complex portfolio of debts with varying and often obscure risk profiles.

Navigating the Future of Private Credit

The private credit market has arrived at a pivotal juncture, facing a choice between two diverging paths. One path leads toward greater complexity, higher leverage, and mounting risk, driven by the relentless pursuit of yield. The other path, championed by leaders like Tarek Omar, calls for a return to the foundational principles of sound lending: transparency, robust security, and contractual clarity. As the market matures, the resilience of these different models will be tested, and the importance of a clear-sighted approach will become increasingly apparent. For entrepreneurs and investors alike, navigating this landscape requires asking the right questions and prioritizing stability over speculation.

Sameer

Sameer is a writer, entrepreneur and investor. He is passionate about inspiring entrepreneurs and women in business, telling great startup stories, providing readers with actionable insights on startup fundraising, startup marketing and startup non-obviousnesses and generally ranting on things that he thinks should be ranting about all while hoping to impress upon them to bet on themselves (as entrepreneurs) and bet on others (as investors or potential board members or executives or managers) who are really betting on themselves but need the motivation of someone else’s endorsement to get there. Sameer is a writer, entrepreneur and investor. He is passionate about inspiring entrepreneurs and women in business, telling great startup stories, providing readers with actionable insights on startup fundraising, startup marketing and startup non-obviousnesses and generally ranting on things that he thinks should be ranting about all while hoping to impress upon them to bet on themselves (as entrepreneurs) and bet on others (as investors or potential board members or executives or managers) who are really betting on themselves but need the motivation of someone else’s endorsement to get there.

See Full Bio