When TBS announced Foul Play with Anthony Davis for February 2025, the network unveiled an unexpected name behind the cameras: Brian Quinn, the Staten Island comedian best known for hidden-camera pranks on Impractical Jokers, would serve as executive producer for the NBA All-Star’s first foray into television production.
The special represents a significant professional pivot for Quinn, who has spent fourteen years primarily in front of cameras rather than behind them. Foul Play features Davis orchestrating elaborate pranks on fellow athletes including Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder Mookie Betts and Los Angeles Lakers guard D’Angelo Russell, a format that draws directly from the Impractical Jokers playbook Brian Quinn has helped refine since 2011.
From Performer to Producer
The collaboration emerged from Davis’s public appreciation for Impractical Jokers and his expressed interest in creating similar content. Rather than simply licensing the format or providing consulting hours, Brian Quinn took an active executive producer role that positioned him as a behind-the-scenes architect. His involvement extended beyond nominal credit, encompassing format consultation, prank design input, and guidance on managing the technical challenges of capturing authentic reactions while maintaining production quality standards.
Quinn’s transition into production work reflects broader changes in how cable comedy operates in 2025. Traditional comedian career trajectories once moved from stand-up clubs to sitcom acting to film roles; contemporary paths increasingly include producing and content strategy roles that leverage performers’ expertise in audience engagement.
The Appeal of Athlete-Driven Comedy
Professional athletes represent an increasingly attractive demographic for comedy content development. Their existing fan bases provide built-in audiences, their competitive personalities often translate well to prank scenarios, and their public personas benefit from humanizing content that displays personality beyond athletic performance.
The special’s format—athletes pranking other athletes—solved a recurring challenge in celebrity prank shows: the power dynamics that make pranks uncomfortable when famous performers target non-celebrities. By keeping pranks within professional sports circles, Foul Play maintained the reciprocal relationship that makes Impractical Jokers work: everyone involved operates at similar status levels, reducing exploitation concerns that plague some hidden-camera formats.
Quinn’s producer role on Foul Play suggests he recognized these dynamics before they became industry conventional wisdom. By February 2025, several athletes had attempted comedy content with mixed results; Davis’s partnership with an established comedy producer provided structural advantages that purely celebrity-driven projects lack.
Production Expertise as Transferable Skill
Brian Quinn’s fourteen years producing Impractical Jokers provided specific technical knowledge applicable to Davis’s project. Hidden-camera comedy requires managing variables that scripted comedy avoids: unpredictable subject reactions, legal clearances for public filming, audio quality in uncontrolled environments, and ethical considerations around consent and deception.
The production timeline for Foul Play coincided with the 2024-2025 NBA season, which required coordination with professional basketball schedules, resulting in narrow, inflexible shooting windows. Quinn’s experience managing similar logistical constraints during Impractical Jokers filming—where the show must work around venue availability, public crowd sizes, and the four performers’ conflicting schedules—translated directly to navigating professional athletes’ limited availability.
Format Innovation and Adaptation
The Foul Play format made specific adaptations to the Impractical Jokers formula that reflect Quinn’s understanding of what elements transfer across contexts. Davis’s special employed a more straightforward prank compilation approach that suited a one-time special rather than ongoing series format.
The special avoided the complex scoring systems and callback humor that Impractical Jokers has developed over fourteen seasons, instead prioritizing accessibility for viewers unfamiliar with the parent show’s conventions. This suggests a producer who understood that Davis’s audience overlaps with but differs significantly from Quinn’s existing fanbase.
Industry observers noted that Foul Play avoided common pitfalls of celebrity-driven prank specials, including overproduced scenarios that telegraph their setup and pranks that rely on humiliating non-celebrities. The special’s athlete-on-athlete approach and relatively naturalistic production style bore clear fingerprints of the Impractical Jokers ethos, even as it adapted those principles to new contexts.
Strategic Career Expansion
Brian Quinn’s executive producer credit on Foul Play marks his first major production role outside The Tenderloins’ owned properties. While Quinn maintains executive producer credits on Impractical Jokers and its various spinoffs, those projects represent internal company work rather than external collaborations.
“I had such an insanely fun time making this with AD,” Quinn posted on X. “ The man knows how to mess with people.”
